lunedì 10 dicembre 2012

Greece and Balkan countries in the annual CPI

This year Greece is on the first place for corruption among the 27 EU member states, according to the organization "Transparency International", which was published last week,in the annual Corruption Perception Index(CPI).
Although the European Union members and the Euro area in particular are at a good level of transparency, and are among the first in the list of least corrupt countries, Greece is an exception, being the only EU member located in the lower half of the list with the most corrupt countries in the world.
Now it stands at 94th place in the list, in comparison to 80th that was last year at, grouped below newer member states and also below poorer member states,such as Bulgaria and Romania.
According to the corruption perception index in the list of 176 countries Greece(in a situation of debt crisis) appears to have greater corruption in the public sector from the EU states, the same of Colombia.
In commentary that the German daily "Der Spiegel" makes  for the list of corrupted countries,it emphasizes that in Greece there are many corrupt officials and politicians who are "bought", considering the situation in the country very alarming,and also noting that Greece is located below the level of Jamaica, China and Rwanda.
According to analysts reports it is an indication that corruption determines also country's economic engine, which means that where there is corruption there are economic problems.
In this Corruption Perceptions Index for 2012, Denmark, Finland and New Zealand occupy the first place, based on their transparency schemes through information systems and the rules that determine the behavior of those holding public office.
While at the end of this "World classification",there are states like Afghanistan, North Korea or Somalia.
This report is based on statistics from 13 international organizations, among them the World Bank,African and Asian financial institutions and the International Economic Forum.
For what regards the aspirant countries of the Western Balkan area, they remain "the black sheep" of the continent, in terms of corruption at high levels of government and the public sector.
In its report, "Transparency International"-Corruption Perception Index for 2012, shows that countries in the region have lost their positions in the overall ranking of 176 countries. Despite the fact that there were countries such as Croatia, Bosnia and Serbia who have achieved the best result, countries such as Albania, Kosovo, Montenegro and Macedonia, remain problematic.Although improved seven positions, Kosova is ranked 105th in the overall standings. Montenegro dropped from 66th place in 75th.Macedonia  remained in the same place, at the 69th, just like last year.
But the Balkans countries know that if they want to join the EU they have to fight against corruption in all level of government, and recently Croatia gave a positive example.
 In fact this last week the former prime minister of Croatia, Ivo Sanader was sentenced to 10 years in prison on corruption charges, including taking bribes from two foreign companies, becoming the most senior official in the former Yugoslavia to face jail time for graft.
Analysts said the ruling was a watershed for the Balkan country, which has pledged to stamp out corruption before joining the European Union in July 2013. Croatia has been struggling to overcome lawlessness and corruption, the legacy of the bloody Balkan wars of the 1990s and decades of Communist rule.
Sasa Segrt, executive director of the Zagreb office of Transparency International, the anti-corruption group, said in an interview by telephone that the aspiration to join the E.U. played a key role in Croatia’s drive to fight corruption, including the attempt to bring Mr. Sanader to justice. Yet she stressed that he received a fair trial and defense.“The Sanader case represents a new notch in the fight against corruption. He represented the epitome of political corruption in Croatia,” she said. “But without EU pressure, things would have moved far more slowly.” In Croatia, analysts said that the sentence sent a powerful message, both at home and in Brussels, that Croatia is serious about fighting corruption.

                  P A R T I C I P A N T S
                        P R O C E S S E S
Transparency International
was published
Greece
is on; being; stands; was; appears to have; is located;
EU members and Euro area
to be a good level; are among;
German daily (material)
makes; emphasizes; considering; noting;
Corrupt official and polticians
are; are “bought”;
It
is
Corruption
determines
Denmark,Finland and New Zealand
occupy
Rules
determine
States
are
Report/CPI
based; shows;
Western Balkan area countries/they/countries
remain; have lost; achieved; remain; isranked; dropped; remained; know; want to join; have to fight;
Croatia
gave; pledged to stamp; joining; has been struggling; is serious
The former prime minister of Croatia/Ivo Sanander
was sentenced; becoming; to face; received; rapresented;
Analysts
said; ruling was; said;
Sasa Segrt
said; stressed; said;
Aspiration to join
played;
Sanander case
rapresents; sent; is;
Things
would; have moved;


Besmir Haxhiaj

____________________

Sources:


http://www.transparency.org/cpi2012


http://www.spiegel.de/international/world/transparency-international-ranks-greece-as-most-corrupt-in-eu-a-871074.html

http://www.bbc.co.uk/news/world-europe-20407006

martedì 4 dicembre 2012

EU commissioner Štefan Füle's speech,held on the occasion of the end of the supervision of independence of Kosovo


This is an analysis of the speech of Štefan Füle (European Commissioner for Enlargement and Neighbourhood Policy) held on the occasion of Kosovo's European Future dinner that marking the end of supervised independence.(Pristina, Kosovo 10 September 2012)
 -In the first paragraph, there is a reference to the audience. He mentions all political representatives of Kosovo, and thanks specially the former President of Finland Marti Ahtisaari, who along with a plan called by his name-Ahtisaari Plan, where proposed a solution to the region of Kosovo. He even thanked and congratulated the head of EU representatives, whom he called by his name Pieter. Moreover, he mentions the American contribution, but although the American impact was crucial for the stability and the independence of Kosovo, Fule mentions the EU representatives by their first names-“Pieter (Feith) and Samuel (Zbogar)”. He is doing this in purpose; he wants to point out that Kosovo is so familiar with the institutions that these people represent that they can recognize them by their first names. He is also dedicating a whole paragraph to the job that is already done by EU officials, showing that the EU is supporting Kosovo. Thus he is trying to show Kosovo’s future is to join the EU, close to its “friends”.
-In the second paragraph Fule mentions some successful examples of Balkan states that integrated, and are in process to join EU. At this point, Fule is talking about the plans that EU has for the region. He is claiming that if the new states meet EU’s expectations, they are welcomed to the European family. Fule is separating the regions, and he is referring only to the Western Balkans, and this does not happen accidentally. He is referring to the sphere of influence that the Eastern Balkans still have from Russia, and that the western Balkans are more open to negotiations with the EU. 
-In the next paragraphs, Fule is dictating the way that Kosovo’s state should manage its internal policy. Fule then mentions the basic principles that should exist in the political environment of Kosovo, such as dialogue. He tries to make stronger by claiming that European Union too is based on these principles. Thus, what Fule is saying is important and should be taken into consideration from the Kosovo’s part. He is giving credibility to his arguments. Fule is continuing with optimistic and promising messages, and is stating that “Kosovo has made great strides on its path to the European Union”. By using the word “great”, he shows that Kosovo has already done some achievements they should be proud of, and that the EU recognizes them. This is a way to tell them that the end of the journey is coming closer, be patient and go on, keep doing the good work, and you will get rewarded. He continues by stating his confidence that Kosovo will soon participate in EU programs, and that's a step closer to european integration. All these are an introduction for upcoming claim. The things that Kosovo has to achieve in order the process to continue. This is a good strategy, Fule is showing the benefits in the beginning, and then is stating as taken for granted, what EU requires from Kosovo: the rule of law, electoral reform, public administration reform, the integration of all communities, and trade.
After the statement of requirements, Fule makes a strong argument. He is claiming that Kosovo holds its destiny in its own hands. He says: “It depends exclusively on your hard… around the European idea”. Fule is appealing to the emotions and the willingness of political entities of Kosovo. If they want it, they can achieve it, it is up to them. This statement puts the burden of decisions to the political units, and actually relief the consciousness of EU for possible failure of diplomatic agreements.
-In all paragraphs of his speech he used the singular pronoun form "I" and almost the same extent the plural pronoun "we" and sometimes "you". For example: "I urge all people in Kosovo to come together ..."; "I call on the leaders of all communities to support..."; "We know that there are still challenges..."; "we successfully completed the third...".He don't speak only as a EU commissioner responsable for Enlargement and Neighbourhood policy but he speaks in the name of the all European Union.        
-At the end,Fule is closing his declaration by stating his belief that the goals will be reached and that Kosovo will be part of EU. This is a good way to bring back the faith portrayed in his speech, after a small interference of doubt. In general, the speech is promoting a sense of optimism and belief in the EU to Kosovo’s case regarding its integration as a future member.

Besmir Haxhiaj

______________
Sources:
http://europa.eu/rapid/press-release_SPEECH-12-594_en.htm
http://www.diplonews.com/feeds/free/11_September_2012_191.php

lunedì 3 dicembre 2012

Joint conference following Russian-German interstate consultation


Joint conference following Russiann-German interstate consultation

The speech that I decided to analyze is divided into two parts, respectively firstly Putin’s intervention and at second Merkel’s one, and was given  on 16th November 2012. It come at the end of the 14th session of interstate consultations between Germany and Russian Federation. I consider very important the outcome thus the approaching dynamic between the two countries is set in the contest of the euro crisis. This kind of conferences at the top could establish new political and economic dynamic. That is the reason why I have chosen to try to construe the introductive part of the Conference at the end of consultations.
The speeches’ structure is the most common one between the political speeches: both are divided into paragraphs, each one of them introduced by a top sentence, which is easily identifiable. Putin’s speech far longer than Merkel’s one, more than doubled. Divided into 7 paragraphs the first one and into five the second. (For information, the speeches’ second part is structured by questions and answers).
Both the politicians start addressing the audience and thanking each other, yet comparing the first paragraph of both speeches some differences raise. Putin addresses the auditorium and Ms Chancellor directly, thanking the “German partners”, German investors as a whole. Ms Merkel addresses the auditorium thanking Putin only. From the very beginning it is evident that in the cooperation process the main role is played by Germany, it is more structured,  involving many forces, political as economic. The Russian one has to be still deployed, being above all political commitment at the moment.
1-9: in the first paragraph Putin thanks the Germans for the cooperation and its quality, addresses the auditorium saying the dialogue is at high level and  talks about the stressed topics. Not only the President  thank the Germans opening his speech but he decides to emphasize it setting at the beginning of the sentence “First of all”. From the lexical point of view the word chosen “cooperation” also is important: cooperation implies closer ties and goals sharing than coordination. To describe Russian-German cooperation he uses the adjectives “constructive” and “fruitful”. Enthusiastically as well, Putin describes the interstates consultation just closed, using the words “significant”, “detailed” and adjective superlative degree for the topic stressed “wides variety of topical issue”. Concluding the first paragraph Putin uses the verb “to confirm” talking about the “special nature of their dialogue”, which suggest us it has existed before and it is getting stronger.
In the first paragraph the first rhetorical device, “repetition”, more specifically “list of three”: both the number of participants – both parties – both the countries. The repetition of “both” raises an important aspect of Putin’s approach: he is talking to Germans on an equality floor, aiming to underline the deep common purpose and positions.
10-18: paragraph completely focused on the economical relations between the two countries and the growth races of their business.   
In the second paragraph, there is the repetition of three twice, in the first part raising for the word “trade”: our trade – bilateral trade – our trade and in the second one for the word “economy”: economic contest – economic situation – Russian economy, both paragraph’s keyword. Along the line above, the lexical choice is shaped by optimistically tones and Putin describes their trade as “well developing economic relations”, they continue “to gain momentum”, “good trend”, “very positive”.
Putin’s viewpoint is clearly understandable by his lexical choice: talking about the economical ties “it suffices to mention (..)” and few lines below “You agree (..) it is a good trend”. It means the situation is obvious, the commercial relations between the two countries are undeniably very positive. Not only they are very positive but Putin uses two adjectives superlative degree to describe the German role in the framework: “some (of) German investment are intended to launch most efficient production and introduce most advance technologies”. To address directly the auditorium using the pronoun “you” is another rhetorical device trying to involve in the consent as much people as possible.
19-29: paragraph dedicated to the German role in Russian economy, German support to Russian accession to WTO, the deep economic cooperation under way. Putin does not pin down on Russian economical sectors where Germany is acting but define them using the words and expressions such as “many”, “strategic” and “operating in almost all of the country’s region”.  Once again enthusiastically tones about German-Russian relations: “potential cooperation is far from exhausted”, “full-scale industrial cooperation”, “innovative breakthrough projects”, “close cooperation”.
Third paragraph, fourth and fifth time the repetition of three, respectively: potential for cooperation – industrial cooperation – close cooperation, Russia’s economy – Russian accession – Russian WTO accession. At the third paragraph detects the use of the pronoun first person singular, different than what officially established (at the beginning/at the end). Here Putin thanks Merkel for the support  to WTO and talks about energy sector. It is evident these two topics lie at his heart.
30-36: paragraph talks about German central role in distributing Russian gas through Europe and bilateral documents and planes. Keywords here are energy and resources. 
Personal pronoun first person singular recurs again, twice: “I must say” and “I am sure”, making us perceive that Putin is convinced and confident with projects’ achievement.
37-43: talking about past and future meetings Putin uses the following words “useful”, “interesting”, “lasting friendship”, “cooperation”, “desire to expend these contacts in all areas”, “new projects and initiatives”, “no smaller number of ideas”. All of them turning into the semantic categories of what is positive, hopeful and proactive. For the sixth and seventh time “repetition of three” device, this time with words referring to the same semantic area than the same words themselves (variation): conference – conversation – consultation, fresh ideas – projects – initiatives.
44-51: at the sixth paragraph it is experimented one of the oldest rhetorical technique, the catch phrase, here “building the future together”. Here Putin broads the topics’ range. Until now economical ties and particularly energy, now “topical international issues”.
52-62: the conclusive paragraph ends using the same rhetoricals as above. On one hand the repetition of three with variation, twice: initiatives – projects – plans, and I would like – I would mention – I would like. On the other one, talking about the German – Russian coordination forum Putin uses n enthusiastically register: “dynamic”, “engaging atmosphere”, “substantive agenda”, “useful forum to discuss the most sensitive (..) controversial issues and proved its relevance and effectiveness”.
Two messages go through the whole Putin’s speech literally holding it together, strategically lying at the beginning, in the centre and at the end.  Both are at the same time repetition of three. The first is Putin’s attitude of gratitude: “I would like to thank our German partners” – “I would like to thank again Ms Federal Chancellor” – “I would like to thank Ms Federal Chancellor and all our partners”. The second is the equality relationship, Germans are partners: German partners – German partners -  our partners.
What is particularly interesting is that comparing the two speeches, the Putin’s one assume different tones than if redden alone. Comparing, it is also possible to notice the different styles arguing the same topics.
First lines have the same meaning and address the same persons but the style is completely different. Ms Federal Chancellor thanks “on behalf of (..) entire delegation” showing a shared responsibility, while Putin says “I would like to thank our German partners”. The reasons itself for what the politicians thank are different: “for the reception in Kremlin” Merkel and “for constructive and fruitful cooperation” Putin. It could mean the consultation has been more convenient for the Russian part.
Both underline the importance of meeting at the top but in a different way: more emotional Putin: “this (..) was significant judged by both the number of participants – almost 30 heads of ministers and agents from both parties – detailed nature of the conversation”. Merkel is delighted as well but more distant: “the number of ministries represented here and the agreements that have been signed reflected the breadth and range of our ties”. The same attitude talking about the 14th session: Putin talks about it at the present tense, Merkel at the past. Putin felt it definitely more.
69-74: Merkel talks about reasons moving German-Russian cooperation. Putin set the relation on an alleged equality floor, Merkel immediately and clearly divided the roles: “Russia has vast resources while Germany would like to help Russia modernize its high-tech sector and infrastructure”. While Putin talks about German businesses present in many and strategic sectors of Russian economy, Merkel mentions numbers: there are more than 6.000 German companies operate in Russia.
To talk for a whole paragraph about the volume of commercial transaction between Russia and Germany is the Putin strategy to maintain the relation on an equality floor even if there is not real reciprocity.  Thus reading Merkel’s speech helps to resize Putin’s one: there is not equality in Russian-German commercial relations, Germans only are investing.
Here it is possible to detect the repetition of three: more than 6.000 German companies – the more predictable – the more our trade will grow.
Merkel’s lexical choice is positive: “strategic partner”, twice “cooperation”, “the current dynamic is clearly positive”, “if predictable investment (..) our trade will grow”.
Leaving the strict analysis of the text for a more general one, the first important point to face is the different styles of the two politicians: Merkel communicates clearly way even if not openly, her speech turns out more indirect than Putin’s one, her style is less emotional and empathetic, e.g. : “what happens within the forum is particularly important”. She was able to sum the session’s outcome in half of a line. On the other hand Putin, who dedicate a whole paragraph to consultations’ outcome with wide use of adjectives: “constructive”, “fruitful”, “significant”, “detailed”, “topic issue”. Putin’s style is long-winded, argumentative, rich, overwhelming in a way. Merkel’s style is dry and clear, minimal. She uses adverbs and indirect ways to communicate her opinion, she does not compose long sentences making us drop the hint than openly saying. The most common adverbs in German speech are: very clear, very lively, very pleased, openly, of course, the more, overall.
Another example to clear the style’s difference: when Putin refers to Merkel as host in Russia calls her “honor host”, doing the same Merkel refers to him by “host” only.
An example of message subtended to words is the following: Merkel starts the second subsection of the third paragraph with “Of course we talked about preparation for Russia’s G20 presidency next year”. Here Merkel’s stance is clear, it is obvious they talked about the Russian presidency of the next G20. It means that the economic investments were long before turned into political influence.
What is important to notice is that the German political influence was never mentioned by Putin as the civil society’s situation in Russia. Both topics accurately avoided by Putin.
Having a common view of the future cooperation, both intend to strengthen the ties between the two countries by participation of the youth. Merkel seems to be deeply convinced about this strategy’s worth saying “we should think about how to improve our youth exchange”, something concrete.
In Merkel’s speech are detectable not only positive words and expressions but words voicing her concern as well, such as: “problems concerning the indebtedness of industrial countries”, “concern about certain legislative projects”, with respect to Putin’s speech where the only non positive words are referred to the undeniable “difficult” economic situation.
Merkel too uses the repetition of three in its double variations: conversation – dialogue – talking and I am – I think – I think.
The frequency in the use of personal pronoun is one of the most important indicators of speaker’s stance, style and message. I noticed that they use the pronoun first person singular in two kind of situations: at the beginning and in conclusion of the speech, as officially demanded, and when they want to talk about something lying to their heart, they consider important even if not specifically concerning the meeting’s topic. Both the politicians use the personal pronoun first person singular four times, in both speeches at the beginning, at the end and in full text. Both Putin and Merkel address each other five times, turning out they have the same importance to each other and in front of the audience.
About the use of personal pronoun first person plural and the possessive pronoun first person plural it is important to notice that across the text they are used differently: when they are referred to  Germans or Russians only and when to German and Russian togheter. In this regard there is curious number of coincidences: in both speeches personal pronoun first person plural referred to the single ethnicity is not detectable, on the other hand, referred to Russians and Germans together, there is respectively 8 times. It means there is a deep common interest and their actions are structured and coordinated. About possessive pronoun first person plural, again it is detectable a singular coincidence: referred to German or Russian only there is 4 times in both speeches, referred to Germans and Russians together nine times. Considering that in the first case in both speeches the pronoun is referred to the partner (our partner), the possessive pronoun referred to Russians-Germans together strongly raises. It means both politicians want to communicate to us the great importance and entity of their project.    
Judging their style they both do not address directly except when they introduce the speech, talking to the auditorium or when, during the speech, they address the other politician.
Judging their approach and skills, both Putin and Merkel show attitude of openness, willingness to engage with each other and not only acceptance of differences but acceptance of them as ground for their cooperation. They both give proof of interpreting skills. Moved by geopolitical and economical necessity the two politicians acted in a clever way, identifying areas of common ground and exploiting them along the line of the past, deep relations between their cultures, as from the text “our lasting friendship”.

Valentina Lonardi




domenica 2 dicembre 2012

Putin "Beslan Speech"

The Beslan massacre crisis was a security and political crisis of September 2004. A group of armed militants, mainly Ingush and Chechen, occupied a school in the town of Beslan for three days. At the end of the standoff, Russian security forces attacked the school using heavy weapons and equipment.
As a result of the crisis, 334 hostages died, including 186 children, with several people reported missing.
The event led to a serious repercussion in Russia, both security and political, and to a series of Federal reforms, which strengthened central power, most notably powers of the President of Russia.
At the end of the crisis, President Vladimir Putin reported some televised remarks.
The speech carries several concepts, and contains different approaches to the issue of the fact that hundreds of people have been murdered both by armed militants and by Russian security forces.
From an overall point of view, the speech appears to be significantly less emotional than the speech held by President Bush in the aftermath of Twin Tower attacks, which is the only other modern superpower's head's speech under attack. In this speech, President Putin talked as a political-military leader who is in control, and not as a sort of "President-father of the Nation" who suffered an astonishing and unexpected attack on its heart: this likely because the siege to the school lasted for three days, permitting the Russian audience to be slightly prepared, and because the military and political unrest in the Transcaucasian region was a really old issue, tracking back the early 1990s. In its speech, he not only regrets for errors and lacks of effort in fight against militants, but also calls to arms the entire country, warning it about its dangers and its enemies: in this case, differently form Bush's speech, Putin proposes a geopolitical analysis about next challenges Russia will have to face to and about Russia's enemies, who in turn are characterized in several points as a sort of "inimici" (in a Schmitt sense), i.e. they must be annihilated and destroyed for the Russia's sake itself.
It is also to note that Putin rejects the idea of "punishment", or of "justice", or of "vengeance". The speech is focused on the general response and on the necessity of defence against terrorists, not on the idea that the act of terror is directed against the Russian way of life.
The first part consists of the introduction and addresses. President Putin talks about an horrible tragedy which has happened to Russia. The tragedy is represented as an impersonal event and as involving not simply "murderers" but someone who used weapons against children. After introducing the theme, President Putin salutes the relatives of those who died. Words used refer mainly to children, characterizing them as parts of relatives' kin and as relatives' "dearest" and "closest" ones. The concept that the massacre "happened" is remarked twice in the first paragraph, while the "children" are the central concept of the second one.
Successively President Putin links Beslan massacre to other "tragic pages" of the Russian national history and, overall, to the collapse of the Soviet Union: he stresses that they all are living under exceptional conditions, and characterizes the present-day country as a mere nucleus of the former giant. The main concept, around which all the subsequent corollaries are formed, is that, despite many difficulties, trials and challenges, Russia still stands as a heir of the Soviet Union. The collapse of the Soviet Union is described as given by "changing conditions", and it is not due to other economic reasons.
In the third part, Putin describes in more detail difficulties and trials faced by Russians. He mentions the transitional economy and, remarkably, the fact that nowadays internal and ethnic conflicts were, at the time, harshly suppressed. It is to note that Putin does not talk about Russia, but about the Soviet Union. In the second paragraph of the three paragraph-long part he lists the conflict-related faults: the Russian Federation stopped paying due attention to the border defence, to the fight against corruption in law enforcement and judiciary, to security system. Eventually, he admits that, despite the collapse, conditions would have been better if the time had been not wasted. The climax is reached, however, at the end of the third paragraph, when Putin stresses that now Russia demonstrates weakness, and that «the weak are beaten».
Most recurring words are related to defence and security, as well as to the meaning of nation and troubles, whilst the vocabulary used is more technical and less emotional than that used in the previous paragraphs.
The fourth part consists of three quasi-independent subparts, talking all about the terrorist threat and about the exact nature of the threat. In first subpart Putin explicitly remarks that terrorist acts and militants are merely instruments, used by those who want to destroy Russia, by cutting away «big chunks» and by weakening a nuclear superpower. In second subpart the President of Russian Federation recalls the beginning of the second major part, although in an inverse meaning: despite the several tragedies, this attack is an attack against all Russia, not only on the State institutions. The last subpart of the fourth major part depicts the false - according to Putin - choice that Russians have: resist or cave in and agree, reaching some compromise, in the hope the terrorist would eventually leave Russia to rest. From a "wordish" point of view, the word "Russia" predominates in all the paragraphs, accompanied by words such as "threat", "challenge" and "help".
The fifth major parts deals with the fact that the choice is not possible and Russia has to reject the temptation of caving in. The main concept is the fight against a broad war which can violate borders and not against individual and uncoordinated forays. Trough this speech, President Putin acknowledges that War on Terror has involved also Russia, and that also Russia will have to haunt terrorists in an international context and in order to do so, it has the duty to upgrade security, judiciary and law enforcement agencies in order to make them capable to deal with new threats. This Russian war on terror needs, however, a general mobilization of the nation, and a general changes of ordinary daily lives. The President also warns that wars do not end quickly and the general attention has to be increased. In this part there is no word clearly recurring, apart of Russia and Terrorists.
In the sixth and last major part, President Putin addresses directly all the Russian citizens. After addressing, Putin list the measures to be taken in order to prepare the whole country to the mentioned Russian war of terror. These include strengthening of "national cohesion", creation of a new system of forces and an affective crisis management system. All of these measure are stressed to be in full accordance with the Constitution.
The speech ends with a call to all Russians to be stronger than terrorists and enemies of Russia by morale, courage and solidarity, claiming that solidarity had been expressed the night before the speech, in the immediate aftermaths of Beslan massacre. The cohesion, a recurring topic in the all-times Russian rhetoric and ideology, is stressed and linked to the humanity. 


Marco Cassini