domenica 4 novembre 2012

Hungarian Gold, the conveted prize of political clashes

Four Freedoms are, in both EU law and policies, the very basic ground, which all the activities of European Union must be based on. These rules - freedom of circulation of workers, of goods, of services and of capitals within EU borders - are the very heart of the non-declared EU Constitution. These rules are also the original aim of the EEC Treaty. No external treaty could even be discussed if the Four Freedoms are not strongly preserved - and if possibly expanded. Through enforcement of Four Freedoms, European Commission was able to greatly expand its own influence.
The freedom of trade - in its broader meaning - implies that no public authority could encourage (not to talk about support) any national-preference policy: on the contrary, there is a precise obligation created upon the States to discourage, where possible, such trade practices. However, if these requirements are absolutely binding for Western Europe countries (the so-called EU-12 or the EU-15), some exemptions were granted to States which were to join in subsequent decade, in order to allow them to provide some self-protection measures.
2000s' enlargements of European Union reached former communist countries when they were to oversee the transition from planned and State-owned economy toward a market-led economy. Each of these States was concerned to preserve its own economic security: Romania limited foreign land buy-up and maintained oil resources under regulation, while several other countries followed similar paths of partly controlled privatization.
Hungary has not mineral resources such as oil, gas or mining allurements. Quite often, it is said that Hungarian gold is the Corn gold, meaning that Hungary has wide fertile regions. This way of saying, however, has more than one reason to be considered extremely appropriated: land is by law valued in the ancient golden crowns of Maria Theresa of Hapsburg. The Hungarian main resource is lot of arable land, over 5.000.000 hectares, which are looked hungrily. In 1994 Hungarian government has enacted a severe moratorium on land purchases by foreigners - either persons or enterprises - which prohibits any foreign entity to buy land within the current borders of the homeland of Saint Stephen I.
This moratorium was prolonged in 2004, when Hungary joined the European Union, in response to the freedoms set under the then EC Treaty. However, the EU institutions expect that this measure is scheduled to lapse at the beginning of June 2014.
The problem is that Government does not agree.
Conservative party Fidesz, currently holding political power in Budapest, is willing to keep the agricultural resources in Hungarian hands. The new agrarian law passed in July 2012 acts in order to ban foreign people from buying agrarian lands after the end of moratorium, and declares null and void any contract made in prevision of the complete market opening.
This will lead - for sure - to a new political clash between European Union and Hungary: the EU is still hostile to the former partner of Austria, and is even more hostile to the current Prime Minister, Viktor Orban. It is easy to assume that the agrarian law will be scrutinized by the European Court of Justice. Anyhow, internal political conditions will be the real determining factor for the future of measures: if the Prime Minister surrenders to the EU laws, this will be exploited by the far-right wing movement Jobbik, in order to depict Orban as a mere drudge of the European Union, and in order to gain the support of small farmers, who currently vote and rely on Fidesz.
Majority of land belongs to few great landowners, sometimes connected to the Hungarian prime minister, and this led to some tensions within the cabinet, because the minister (State Secretary) for Agriculture resigned in protest against these connections. Also other conservatives are against the so-called "Orange" Land Barons (Orange is the Fidesz's colour). If the EU line will prevail, Orban will be weakened and alongside Orban a barrier against anti-EU nationalists will be seriously compromised.


Marco Cassini

Nessun commento:

Posta un commento