domenica 25 novembre 2012

Putin and Medvedev welcome Obama’s re-election[i] (corrections)

How Obama’s second term can influence the Reset. Leading analysts’ opinions

Since the Cold War, Russia has followed the American presidential elections very closely as U.S. have always been the major factor in Russia’s domestic and foreign politics. No exception for these elections.
This first paragraph introduces briefly both the candidates from Russian point of view. Since World War II, there has not been any deep difference between Republican and Democratic administrations when it came to basic national security policy. However it is possible to stress some differences depending on historical conjuncture and the President’s personality. Romney has never hidden his anti-Russian rhetoric coming to state on the eve of the elections “Russia as United States No. one geopolitical foe”. This would have played as a strategic tool into the hands of those who set the course of Russian domestic policy. An opponent of Russia at the White House would help to rally the conservative segment of the electorate and the ruling elite around the Kremlin's anti-U.S. agenda.
On the other hand, Obama. Considering the traditional democratic credentials only, these make him perceived as carrying on a less aggressive foreign policy and generally more tolerant. Obama’s victory means U.S.-Russian relations will not return to the post-Soviet climate experienced during Bush’s administration. From the very beginning Obama set down the Reset Policy. Aware of the importance of Russian cooperation to fulfill the most important tasks of his agenda, namely global nuclear annihilation and climate change, he realized the need to rearrange strong dialog if not ties with Russia. In the first half of his term, the Reset Policy reached its peak with the New Start, a bilateral agreement on nuclear weapons reduction. The process cooled with the new Putin’s presidency stranding on the missile shield set in Europe. Obama’s re-election could be the chance for a mutually acceptable configuration of U.S. missile defense in Europe on one hand and on the other one to safeguard Russian deterrent potential. Moreover, Obama’s presidency is ultimately much more favorable for Russia for at least three other reasons. At first, his unofficial statement of more flexibility during his second term. Secondly, he has no particular political or personal interest in antagonizing Russia, attitude detectable for instance in his support to a softer version of Magnitsky Bill and the Jackson-Vanik law, respectively avoiding interferences in Russian domestic politics and trade-barriers. Eventually, Russia has the opportunity to secure agreement with U.S. in areas of its own interest as Obama has not Bush’s desire to promote directly “colored revolution” in Russia’s backyard.
Immediately after the re-election of the U.S. current President Mr. Obama, the Kremlin sent to the White House a congratulatory telegram where Putin cheered him hoping for “constructive” cooperation “substantive and open dialogue” with Washington.
Both the President and the Prime Minster of Russian Federation generally welcomed Obama’s re-election. Different sources portray Medvedev as raised, describing Obama as “understandable and predictable partner.” Asked about the Reset Medvedev answered:“somewhat (was) successful and somewhat not but will need to continue” showing himself sure about how to bring it forward:“The Obama’s administration formulated a strategy for Russia four years ago, and we will follow it now”.
It was not a secret Medvedev considered Obama his man at the White House.  In this regard the Russian Prime Minster stated: “I am happy that the President of a very big, very influential state is not a man who consider Russia to be its enemy number one. (..) It is some kind of paranoia”, clearly referring to Romney’s speech.
Putin is pleased with the result. Speaking through his Press Secretary Dmitry Peskov, the President said:“We express hope that the positive beginnings in bilateral relations and in international cooperation between Russia and the United States in the interest of global security and stability will continue to develop and improve”. Peskov went on saying “We are ready - on the basis of mutual equality, mutual benefit and mutual respect - to go as far as the U.S. administration is willing to go”.
All in all it seems the immediate reactions have been set reactions. Below, experts’ analysis and their opinions on Reset Policy.
A large part of analysts seems to be convinced the Reset Policy will continue. Despite the differences between them, they all are convinced Mr Obama will shape U.S. – Russia relations. The chairman of the Federation Council’s International Affairs Committee Margelov argues it will carry on even by halting manner. “U.S. foreign policy under the re-elected President Obama will be carried out on an ‘incentive-purpose principle’ that is virtually unpredictable in terms of what the incentive will be, what the responses will be and even what the relationship with Russia will be”. Of the same mind Trentin, pointing out a double-policies strategy for Washington to follow in order to reset its ties with Moscow: to solve NATO’s planned missile defense shield issue and cooperation in exploring  the Arctic. The Russian Prime Minster himself stated the conduct of relations among them will be along the lines set out four years ago. Levichev, head of a Duma faction, said Obama now has free hand to pursue the Reset predicting that it could be even more successful.
On the other hand the analysts arguing that the future cooperation hangs largely on Moscow. Karaganov, head of the Council for Foreing and Defense Policy, talks about Russian general position saying:“if Russia is perceived as waning power, then tensions may increase. If not, then I think we will see cool, practical cooperation”. Nemtsov, co-leader of the Republican Party “People’s Freedom Party” focuses more directly on the problem: “the biggest problem was in Moscow, not in Washington. Putin is dependent on aggressive anti-Americanism. He needs an enemy”.
Zhirinovsky, leader of the Liberal Democratic Party and a Duma deputy speaker, is convinced that nothing much will happen during Obama’s second term.“He will travel abroad and won’t solve domestic problems” de facto leaving Putin free to lay down Russian foreign policy without significant interferences.
There are those who argue that, whether Reset Policy changes or not, it failed. “If you look at the Reset as the attempt to raise relations to a new quality and to move geopolitical interest closer, then it has failed” stated Pushkov.
Those who are active in the opposition movement would have preferred Romney to win. Between them Piontkovsky who says a Republican President would make fewer compromises. Like mind is Kasparov, former chess world champion, who called Obama’s Reset Policy “a disaster giving Putin everything he wants.”
One last category rallies analysts who think the Reset Policy is over. Once again Piontkovsky who dejected says “that even under Obama the reset would soon be a thing of the past. The U.S. has bigger problems than Russia and will forget this reset”.  Lukyanov, Editor-in-Chief of the Russian in Global Affairs, completes the analysis saying that “the reset cannot go on because it was a one-time trading of interests. It was a success but it’s over and done with”.
According to authoritative voice of Bavev, Professor with the “Peace Research Institute Oslo” it makes little sense to try predictions. The third Putin’s presidency is totally different than Medvedev’s one and his two previous thus it does not make any sense “to continue policies that worked between Obama and former President Medvedev”. Putin set down his campaign on anti-Americanism and he does not aim anymore to build personal networks among global peers. The scenario is completely changed.
Summarizing what above, Pro-Western oppositions have limited expectations of how Obama’s second term would affect mutual relations and analysts generally agree with each other over the fact that it will be hard to breathe new life into U.S.-Russian relations during Obama’s second term.
It is certain that whether the Reset Policy will continue, both U.S. and Russia should be agree to tackle the most serious issues between them such as differences over NATO’s missile shield in Europe, substantial and mutual reduction of nuclear weapon. Afghanistan, Iran  and Middle East,  integration  with the Western system of the former Soviet Republics - process that U.S. are supporting - the harsher Obama’s position on human rights and democracy in Russia. This everything in a context where the economic ties are not strong enough to promote rapprochement.
As mentioned above referring to Professor Bavev, it does not make sense to make previsions considering that previsions are potential developments grounding on the past and the past does not look even remotely like the present.



[i] http://www.themoscowtimes.com (How Obama’s second term can influence the reset; Putin congratulates Obama on re-election; Reset run out of gas; Russia-U.S. reset likely to lose momentum), http://www.thehindu.com (Putin, Medvedev welcome Obama re-election)


Nessun commento:

Posta un commento